Biosolids Master Plan
We are developing a Biosolids Master Plan (BMP) that will determine how we will manage our biosolids in an environmentally sound, sustainable and cost-effective manner, while meeting Provincial regulations.
The Biosolids Master Plan was submitted to the Province in September 2014 and the letter of approval was received by the City in March 2016. A copy of the Biosolids Master Plan, the Annual Progress Reports and the letter of approval can be found on the Manitoba Sustainable Development (formerly named Manitoba Conservation and Water Stewardship) website.
The City is exploring multiple beneficial reuse strategies for maximum flexibility and robustness.
The City started a two-year biosolids compost pilot on May 4, 2015 with a portion of the biosolids.
The City is exploring land application as a sustainable reuse strategy for a portion of the biosolids. A Request for Information (RFI) was posted on our procurement website in December 2015 to determine the details for a land application contract and the strategy for biosolids storage. RFI submissions were received in February 2016 and reviewed by the City. The City met with the Province in April 2016 to discuss options for the land application program. The Request for Proposal (RFP) for land application was posted on our procurement website in August 2016 and the contract was awarded in December 2016. The land application program includes public engagement, applying for an environmental licence from the Province and a pilot project to apply 5,000 wet tonnes of biosolids to local farmland.
Moving forward the City will implement thermal hydrolysis pretreatment to reduce the quantity and to enhance the quality of the biosolids. This will be done as part of the NEWPCC BNR upgrade. Further details can be found in the RFP for the NEWPCC project
- Stakeholder Advisory Committee
Biosolids, more commonly called sewage sludge, is the nutrient-rich end-product of sewage treatment. It contains significant quantities of organic nitrogen and phosphorus, as well as trace amounts of minerals that are beneficial for plant growth. Biosolids also contain metals and other material that are quite often limited by regulation or licence.
At the sewage treatment plants, the solids are separated from the wastewater. These solids, which consist mainly of organic matter, are then treated and dewatered. At the end of the process, the solids become biosolids.
The City's three sewage treatment plants produced about 13,500 dry tonnes of biosolids in 2012. This is expected to increase to 23,000 dry tonnes by 2037.
Biosolids are provincially regulated, which includes production, transport, use (including beneficial use) and disposal.
Up until January 1, 2011, we would deliver, spread and incorporate a portion of our biosolids into agricultural land at no cost to landowners. The amount would vary depending on a number of factors (e.g., weather). For example, in 2010, we applied 48% of the biosolids on the land.
As a result of concerns about nutrient overloading in Lake Winnipeg, a Provincial regulation was enacted that prohibited the spreading of biosolids on land in winter, and decreased the loading rate of biosolids to farmland. Consequently, we have been landfilling biosolids at Brady Resource Management Facility (Brady Landfill).
We are also moving forward with a two-year, $7 million pilot program to compost biosolids at the Brady Resource Management Facility (Brady Landfill), which will be able to compost 20% of our biosolids. Depending on the results of the pilot, the composting option could be a long term solution for dealing with all or part of Winnipeg's biosolids.
Developing a Master Plan
We issued a Request for Information for Biosolids Management (RFI) to identify groups and gauge the interest in the beneficial reuse of biosolids. This will help us understand the market and the financial implications for biosolids reuse.
Some potential beneficial reuse options for biosolids include:
- combustion with beneficial reuse (e.g., ash, energy capture)
- heat drying to form fertilizer-like pellets and applied to the land to utilize nutrients for agriculture, tree farms and land rehabilitation areas
- raw material for industrial processes (e.g., cement manufacturing, glass aggregate manufacturing, fertilizer manufacturing)
- applying to agricultural land meeting nutrient guidelines
Jul ‐ Oct 2013
Post RFI and hold information session
Nov ‐ Dec 2013
Evaluate RFI responses and identify potential options
Obtain feedback through public participation
Jan ‐ Sept 2014
Develop a Biosolids Master Plan
Submit Biosolids Master Plan to the Province
|Jul ‐ Oct 2013||Post RFI and hold information session|
|Nov ‐ Dec 2013||Evaluate RFI responses and identify potential options|
|Early 2014||Obtain feedback through public participation|
|Jan ‐ Sept 2014||Develop a Biosolids Master Plan|
|Oct 2014||Submit Biosolids Master Plan to the Province|
- Biosolids Master Plan (Pending regulatory review)
- Summary of Request for Information for Biosolids Management
- Public Participation Report
- Public Meetings Questions & Responses
- Glossary of Wastewater Terms
- Public meeting presentation | En Français (January 2014)
- Public meeting storyboards (January 2014)
- Press release: Public invited to a public meeting to comment on the future of biosolids (January 2014)
- Invitation to a Public Meeting to Comment on the Future of Biosolids (January 2014)
- Public meeting advertisement (January 2014)
- RFI information session presentation (September 2013)
- Press release: Private sector firms invited to a Biosolids Reuse Project information session on September 5, 2013 (September 2013)
- Press release: Private Sector Firms Invited to Submit a Proposal for Biosolids Reuse (July 2013)
Frequently Asked Questions
Biosolids are a nutrient-rich, solid by-product of wastewater treatment. At Winnipeg's sewage treatment plants, the solids are separated from the liquid wastewater. These solids, also known as sludge, consist mainly of organic matter, are further treated and dewatered. After treatment, the solids are called biosolids.
- We are required to submit a Biosolids Master Plan to the province by October 2014, with the following considerations:
- sustainable reuse of biosolids and/or end product(s)
- utilization of nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorous)
- possible energy recovery
The Biosolids Master Plan must outline a strategy to manage biosolids to 2037.
We typically review master plans when:
- a major system component requires upgrading,
- there is a significant change to regulatory requirements (e.g., Environment Act licences for the sewage treatment plants).
Yes. In Canada, production, transport, use (including beneficial use) and disposal of biosolids are regulated on a provincial/territorial basis.
About 13,500 dry tonnes of biosolids were produced in 2012.
- Non-biosolids related material (e.g., grit, miscellaneous solid waste material) is landfilled at the Brady Road Resource Management Facility.
- Quantities vary greatly on a seasonal basis (e.g., increased grit enters the system in the winter from sanding of roads and runoff in the spring).
- Non-biosolids material generated in 2012:
- 2375 tonnes at the north end plant
- 622 tonnes at the south end plant
- 210 tonnes at the west end plant
- Biosolids management is an issue world-wide, particularly with more stringent regulations, environmental concerns and social change.
- A variety of management options for biosolids are in use in Canada, including:
- land revitalization/restoration (landfill cover, large construction sites, surface strip mines, parks and road cuts, wetlands, wildlife habitat and conservation areas)
- land application
- thermal oxidation
- landfill (not considered sustainable reuse)
- Up until January 1, 2011, we would deliver, spread and incorporate a portion of our biosolids into agricultural land at no cost to landowners. The amount would vary depending on a number of factors (e.g., weather). For example, in 2010, we applied 48% of the biosolids on the land.
- Since then, we have been landfilling biosolids at Brady Resource Management Facility (Brady Landfill).
As a result of concerns about nutrient overloading in Lake Winnipeg, a Provincial regulation was enacted that prohibited the spreading of biosolids on land in winter, and decreased the loading rate of biosolids to farmland.
- Yes. We are moving forward with a $7 million two-year pilot program to compost biosolids at the Brady Resource Management Facility, which will be able to compost 20% of our biosolids.
- Composting biosolids produces a stable end product high in organic matter which can be used as a soil amendment.
- Depending on the results of the pilot, the composting option could be a long term solution for dealing with all or part of Winnipeg's biosolids.
- We will be looking for the most cost effective option or combination of options.
- This is the first time we have explored external interest, so it is too early to know.
- This Request for Information will help us understand the market implications.
Yes, this is a consideration in assessing possible solutions.
- The treatment processes at the North End Sewage Treatment Plant currently have some older technology (e.g., clarifiers used in biosolids treatment) as well as some recent upgrades with state-of-the-art technology (e.g., ultraviolet light disinfection to reduce pathogens).
- Some of the older technology is still considered effective/best practice (e.g., clarifiers and anaerobic digesters in the biosolids treatment process).
- In July 2010, City Council enacted a new Sewer By-Law that included a new Pollution Prevention Planning Program for industries that is intended to reduce or possibly eliminate pollutants of potential concern.
- This program shifts the focus of wastewater treatment from control to prevention at source, and requires business and industry to continually evaluate materials, processes and practices involved in their operations.
- Industries not in compliance with the by-law limits must, within a specified time period, provide detailed plans to get into compliance or be subject to fines.
- Many compounds of concern are difficult to control in that they are excreted naturally into the sewer system (e.g., medications not fully metabolized, hormones).
- There are limits in the Sewer By-Law for many contaminants and industries out of compliance are subject to the Pollution Prevention Program.
- Research on the impact of emerging compounds of concern on the environment is ongoing, and the City and the Province are following the research developments with the intent of controlling their discharge where sources and control methods can be identified.
- No. Composting toilets aren't an option for our urban setting primarily for the protection of public health, and therefore do not comply with the National Plumbing Code and are prohibited under the City of Winnipeg Sewer By-Law.
- Composting toilets are more suited to small rural communities (e.g., Whiteshell) where the population is very small, and environmental considerations and isolation preclude the use of other systems.
- Yes. The main portions of the composting process that have the potential to create odours are covered with wood chips. This would include the area where the biosolids are mixed with bulking agents.
- The pilot program will evaluate the effectiveness of all the odour control measures, including a biofilter.
- The biosolids composting facility will operate independently of the leaf and yard waste composting operation, at least initially, to allow for a proper evaluation of each operation.
- There will be overlap in those areas that can optimize operating costs, but won't impact the evaluation (e.g., equipment, staff).
No. The void spaces would not be adequate for proper air circulation.
Yes. We will purchase recycled tree waste woodchips for the pilot.
No. The anaerobic composting process is more complex to manage and operate because it requires:
- additional resources to handle the methane gas that it produces, and
- a reliable source of food waste (e.g., a kitchen organics curbside collection program).
We would first have to evaluate the potential for nuisance odour.
- No. The licence for the two-year pilot program does not allow for the composted material to leave the site. We will use the compost on-site as landfill cover and as a soil revitalization material.
- Before we can distribute to a market off-site, we must first be able to demonstrate that the finished compost material is pathogen free and qualifies a "Class A" product.
Additional components can be added to increase the composting capacity if that is a decision of the Master Plan.
We will be evaluating:
- the impact on surrounding neighbourhoods (e.g., nuisance odour), and
- operational requirements (e.g., availability of suitable bulking agents).
Land Revitalization and Landfilling
There is more than 100 years of landfill capacity, including the option of landfilling 100% of biosolids.
This land application program was discontinued in 2010 due to more stringent provincial nutrient regulations under the Water Protection Act as a result of concerns about nutrient overloading in Lake Winnipeg.
- Yes. The province has defined soil types where spreading of biosolids is permitted as well as the quantity of biosolids permitted to be spread.
- The soil types are based on a site specific analysis of nitrogen and phosphorous for defined depths of soil for each nutrient.
- 3.3%N : 2.3%P
- 1.4N : 1P
- The provincial Nutrient Management Regulations do not currently permit more intense spreading rates.
- The allowable spreading rates are based on soil analyses, particularly for background phosphorous concentrations prior to spreading.
The Province of Manitoba Nutrient Management Regulation governs the application of biosolids to land
The Province of Manitoba outlines crop restrictions in the environmental licences for land application programs. The following crops can be grown for a period of three years after the application of biosolids: cereal crops, forage crops, oil seed crops, field peas, soybeans, lentils and corn. After the three year period, farm producers are not restricted to what they can grow. Biosolids land application is not permitted on direct edible crops (i.e., potatoes, carrots, onions).
Land application of biosolids has minimal risk to the environment, provided all regulations are followed. The biosolids land application program will comply with all provincial regulations, including the provincial Nutrient Management Regulation.
The purpose of the Nutrient Management Regulation is to protect water quality by encouraging responsible nutrient application. The Regulation has defined zones that determine where biosolids can be applied. Biosolids cannot be applied in the nutrient buffer zone, which includes land near water bodies, wetlands, groundwater features, flood zones, etc.
The nutrients are concentrated in the ash that remains after firing the biosolids.
- Depending on the concentration of contaminants in the ash, it can be land applied to utilize the phosphorous in the ash.
- We are not aware of technologies to extract the phosphorous from the ash.
Yes. Ash can be applied to land as long as the concentration of metals complies with the provincial Nutrient Management Regulation.
The treatment process of pelletization (heat and drying) kills the pathogens, resulting in a Class A product.
- Yes. The Canadian Food Inspection Agency and the Canadian Council of Ministers of the Environment both have standards for heavy metals content of marketable fertilizer product.
- A granulated product from Winnipeg's biosolids is expected to meet these standards and could be registered as a fertilizer. However, the final product would also be required to meet certain physical characteristics to be deemed as marketable.
Request for Information Process
- This Request for Information (RFI) is a key part of the process in developing a long term plan for managing Winnipeg's biosolids.
- It will help us understand private sector interest and the financial implications for biosolids reuse.
- We will evaluate and consider all proposals.
- We used the following activities to communicate the RFI:
- issued news releases (August 2, September 3),
- advertised in local papers,
- posted information on the City's website on a dedicated biosolids web page,
- contacted relevant vendors, and
- hosted an information session.
Stakeholder Advisory Committee
As part of our public engagement strategy we have brought together a Stakeholder Advisory Committee to bring a variety of perspectives to the table, including technical experts, resource, industry and citizen representatives with an interest or stake in biosolids waste management topics. The role of the Stakeholder Advisory Committee is to review and provide input on options for biosolids management, and provide input on and engage in the public participation process.
The purpose of the Stakeholder Advisory Committee is to provide input on options for biosolids management and on public participation in the Biosolids Master Plan (BMP) process. Input provided will be incorporated into decision making to the maximum extent possible.
|Consumers Association of Canada (Manitoba)||Gloria Desorcy|
|Green Action Centre||Sylvie Hébert|
|International Institute of Sustainable Development||Karla Zubrycki|
|Keystone Agricultural Producers||Curtis McRae|
|Manitoba Conservation||Robert Boswick|
|Manitoba Composting Association (MCAC)||Gérard (Gerry) Dubé|
|Compo-Stages Manitoba Services Co-op (CSMSC)|
|Manitoba Environmental Industries Association||Tanis Ostermann|
|Manitoba Hydro||D.R. (Deny) St. George|
|Lake Friendly||Colleen Sklar|
|Partnership of the Manitoba Capital Region|
|Winnipeg Chamber of Commerce||Dave Angus|
Meeting Presentation and Notes
Meeting #3 - December 5, 2013
Meeting #2 - November 18, 2013
Meeting #1 - October 1, 2013
We invite you to a public meeting to comment on the potential options for managing biosolids.
Tuesday, January 14, 2014
Manitoba Children's Museum,
45 Forks Market Road
|5:30 ‐ 6:00 pm||Registration and coffee|
|6:00 ‐ 6:30 pm||Presentation|
|6:30 ‐ 7:30 pm||Question and answer period|
We will include public feedback in our final report.
If you cannot make it to the meeting, we encourage you to leave your feedback online.